FirstLightErnest

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Tuesday, 9 October 2012

Cyclops Was Right? Has The World Gone Topsy-Turvy?

Posted on 11:34 by Unknown
I'm not sure I'm ready for a Marvel Universe where Cyclops gets to be right. Especially since it's given him a martyr complex. Gad, he'll be insufferable. Thing is, was he right?

Yes, Hope used the Phoenix Force to restore mutants, just as Cyclops said. But there seems to be an implication Hope needed the training she received in K'un-Lun to actually control the giant space bird. Without that, it's likely she'd have gone the same route Scott and the rest of the Phoenix 5 ultimately went.

Of course, I get the impression no one writing the damn crossover ever explicitly pointed this out. Which isn't surprising. You'd think people co-writing a book would bother to get things straight. Or their editors - oh right, never mind. Anyway, it would have been a nice way to deflate Scott. Point out that if he had simply thrown Hope in front of the Phoenix unprepared, it'd have been a disaster. Have Hope be the one, as she tells him what it felt like to try and control an ancient, incredibly powerful force hellbent on destruction.

Because I have a hard time believing restoring mutantkind is what the Phoenix actually came there to do. If so, why does it need a host? Just spread its wings, and make the magic happen. Why destroy a bunch of innocent planets? Surely the Giant Space Fire Bird is maneuverable enough to avoid them? That's not even getting into the question of why the Phoenix cares what the Scarlet Witch did.

Ultimately the results were  what Cyclops wanted, so I guess he doesn't care about the methods. Ends justify the means, and all that. Considering the circumstances though, calling Cyclops "right" is a stretch. If the Avengers had stayed out of it, assuming Wolverine and his crew of X-Folks didn't step in*, the Earth would have been destroyed, which puts the kibosh on Cyclops "restore mutants" dream. Then again, maybe he wouldn't care. I get the impression Cyke doesn't think Earth should continue to exist if there aren't mutants. Which is at least one more good reason to not like Scott Summers. Add it to the pile, then.

* I don't know if they would have. Did they even know the Phoenix was on its way until the Avengers showed up and started throwing their weight around? That's the really disappointing thing from the Avengers' standpoint. If they had just been more reasonable, they could have come out looking a lot better in contrast to Cyclops' idiocy, I mean zealotry.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in avx, cyclops | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • A Dash Through The Solicits
    Three things relevant to me in the latest batch of solicitations: - New Atomic Robo mini-series! Savage Sword of Doctor Dinosaur! I wonder...
  • Sharpe's Rifles - Bernard Cornwell
    I was originally going to hand the box of Cornwell books back to my father unread the next time I saw him. But I got bored, they were sittin...
  • It Takes Real Brains To Always Avoid Illumination
    I mentioned in my review of Daredevil 20 & 21 that I believe the shadowy figures responsible for the creation of Coyote are also the peo...
  • The Ink-Stained Trail - Chapter 4
    The following day got off to a late start. Overslept, though you wouldn't know it from how cotton-stuffed my head felt. A shower only he...
  • What I Bought 2/25/2013 - Part 4
    Only one book today, since Katana #1 didn't show up. Even with it, I would have only had 8 books over that 4-week stretch. There've...
  • The Road To Rule Needs Repaving
    I finished Fable 3 a week or two ago. There are still money-making quests I could do, but I'd beaten the big challenge, and earned enou...
  • What I Bought 6/6/2012 - Part 4
    For a while there, I'd convinced myself I would ask Jack not to send the AvX tie-ins for Secret Avengers . Just ditch the book for a fe...
  • A May Look At The June Previews Of The August Releases
    The solicits for August releases are out, and there's a little good news, a little bad news, and a few things that are exasperating. - G...
  • What I Bought 5/27/2013 - Part 1
    Yep, it's another round of reviewing several weeks' worth of comics. Factor in sporadic book reviews and the other usual stuff and t...
  • The Red Fox - Anthony Hyde
    'I had disappeared. The car had disappeared. For one night at least, I could enjoy the greatest freedom - or horror - conceivable in a t...

Categories

  • 52 (1)
  • absurdity (6)
  • adam warlock (1)
  • amanda waller (2)
  • angel and faith (22)
  • ann nocenti (9)
  • arcade (1)
  • art (7)
  • asimov (6)
  • atomic robo (13)
  • avengers (2)
  • avengers arena (8)
  • aviation (2)
  • avx (8)
  • batgirl (4)
  • batman (5)
  • batman beyond (12)
  • bkv (2)
  • black cat (1)
  • black widow (2)
  • blackest night (1)
  • blogkeeping (2)
  • books (57)
  • btvs (6)
  • burn notice (74)
  • busiek (1)
  • cable/deadpool (1)
  • captain america (8)
  • captain marvel (11)
  • christos gage (3)
  • civil war (1)
  • clint eastwood (2)
  • comicon (5)
  • cyclops (3)
  • daredevil (13)
  • darkwing duck (1)
  • dbz (1)
  • dc (1)
  • DCnu (9)
  • death (9)
  • defenders (7)
  • dial h (9)
  • diversions (30)
  • doug tennapel (2)
  • dr. doom (1)
  • dr. strange (2)
  • dreams (3)
  • dustin nguyen (1)
  • dwayne mcduffie (2)
  • earthworm jim (4)
  • episode rundowns (74)
  • faith (1)
  • fantastic four (2)
  • fashion (3)
  • favorite games (5)
  • flash (2)
  • food (1)
  • gabriel hardman (1)
  • ghost rider (1)
  • grammar (3)
  • green arrow (11)
  • green lantern (4)
  • grifter (1)
  • grimjack (1)
  • hair (1)
  • hawkeye (13)
  • hawkeye and mockingbird (1)
  • heroclix (5)
  • holiday (3)
  • huntress (2)
  • hypothetical (26)
  • ink-stained trail (13)
  • iron fist (3)
  • iron man (1)
  • jack kirby (1)
  • jla (9)
  • joe casey (2)
  • joe kubert (1)
  • katana (3)
  • kelly sue deconnick (1)
  • lex luthor (1)
  • madrox (1)
  • movies (69)
  • mr. fantastic (1)
  • music (2)
  • mystique (1)
  • nightwing (1)
  • norm breyfogle (1)
  • nova (1)
  • nu52 (1)
  • oracle (1)
  • ostrander (2)
  • panda (13)
  • peter milligan (1)
  • photos (3)
  • proposal (9)
  • proposal spider-man (1)
  • pull (11)
  • punisher (1)
  • question (1)
  • rants (15)
  • rebekah isaacs (2)
  • rebels (1)
  • resurrection man (4)
  • reviews (88)
  • rick remender (4)
  • robin (2)
  • rocketeer (7)
  • roger stern (2)
  • rogue (2)
  • romita (1)
  • runaways (1)
  • science (10)
  • sean mckeever (1)
  • secret avengers (20)
  • sergio leone (3)
  • sherlock holmes (2)
  • sienkiewicz (1)
  • skreemer (1)
  • solicits (9)
  • spider-man (5)
  • spike (1)
  • spoiler (4)
  • sports (7)
  • stacy x (1)
  • starfire (1)
  • suicide squad (4)
  • superman (3)
  • tales from the woods (10)
  • theory (50)
  • time travel (6)
  • tv (80)
  • ultimate spider-man (1)
  • ultron (1)
  • uncalvinpitt (2)
  • venom (1)
  • video games (32)
  • warbird (6)
  • wildcats (1)
  • wolverine (2)
  • x-factor (2)
  • x-men (10)
  • year in review (6)

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (208)
    • ►  August (8)
    • ►  July (30)
    • ►  June (30)
    • ►  May (26)
    • ►  April (29)
    • ►  March (28)
    • ►  February (27)
    • ►  January (30)
  • ▼  2012 (292)
    • ►  December (28)
    • ►  November (29)
    • ▼  October (31)
      • The Road To Rule Needs Repaving
      • Let's Talk Favorite XBox Games
      • Welcome to Havana, Senor Hemingway - Alfredo Jose ...
      • Burn Notice 3.12 - Noble Causes
      • How To Transition To This From Yesterday
      • Shock
      • Beat the Devil
      • Hemingway's Boat - Paul Hendrickson
      • In the Mouth of Madness
      • I'm Coming To Accept Conquest Is The Only Way To G...
      • Burn Notice 3.11 - Friendly Fire
      • The More He Struggles, The More He Sinks
      • Busy Now, Come Back Later
      • What Might Have Been
      • Hickey & Boggs
      • I Can't Imagine Everyone Got The Cool Powers
      • Let This Be A Lesson To Take The First Available S...
      • Burn Notice 3.10 - A Dark Road
      • The Lying Tongue - Andrew Wilson
      • Even As An Old Man, Wayne's Still The Master Of Om...
      • Treating AvX With All The Seriousness It Demands
      • Found Wanting - Robert Goddard
      • Cyclops Was Right? Has The World Gone Topsy-Turvy?
      • What I Bought 10/5/2012
      • Burn Notice 3.9 - Long Way Back
      • The Bigger They Are, The More Likely They Die
      • What I Bought 9/21/2012 - Part 6
      • What I Bought 9/21/2012 - Part 5
      • The Savage Garden - Mark Mills
      • What I Bought 9/21/2012 - Part 4
      • What I Bought 9/21/2012 - Part 3
    • ►  September (29)
    • ►  August (30)
    • ►  July (29)
    • ►  June (30)
    • ►  May (31)
    • ►  April (30)
    • ►  March (25)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile